Poker Forum > Live Updates
UKCOAP Day 3 - Main Event Day 1 / Hi Roller
Laxie:
--- Quote from: AJDUK on August 25, 2013, 16:16:55 PM ---
--- Quote from: MarkTheShark on August 25, 2013, 14:47:31 PM ---
Question for discussion - views/comments welcome :
Dealer dealing hole cards (as he does!) accidently flips a card - and immediately retracts the card, saying its the first burn.
If the player to whom it was dealt says "thats my card, i want it - i dont care if all the table knows i have it" should he be allowed to keep it and play continue?
Should the player be allowed the option of keeping that card - on the basis it was his but dealer error has caused them not to get it?
--- End quote ---
Short answer is no. It can create an unfair advantage. You can"t show cards at any point in the hand and this situation shouldn"t be treated any differently.
--- End quote ---
What he said
Santino67:
--- Quote from: Laxie on August 25, 2013, 16:17:49 PM ---
--- Quote from: AJDUK on August 25, 2013, 16:16:55 PM ---
--- Quote from: MarkTheShark on August 25, 2013, 14:47:31 PM ---
Question for discussion - views/comments welcome :
Dealer dealing hole cards (as he does!) accidently flips a card - and immediately retracts the card, saying its the first burn.
If the player to whom it was dealt says "thats my card, i want it - i dont care if all the table knows i have it" should he be allowed to keep it and play continue?
Should the player be allowed the option of keeping that card - on the basis it was his but dealer error has caused them not to get it?
--- End quote ---
Short answer is no. It can create an unfair advantage. You can"t show cards at any point in the hand and this situation shouldn"t be treated any differently.
--- End quote ---
What he said
--- End quote ---
And what they both said ;)
adilong1:
Wayne Parker
Chris Hiam
Barry Simpson
Stuart Oliver
Please
MarkTheShark:
--- Quote from: AJDUK on August 25, 2013, 16:16:55 PM ---
--- Quote from: MarkTheShark on August 25, 2013, 14:47:31 PM ---
Question for discussion - views/comments welcome :
Dealer dealing hole cards (as he does!) accidently flips a card - and immediately retracts the card, saying its the first burn.
If the player to whom it was dealt says "thats my card, i want it - i dont care if all the table knows i have it" should he be allowed to keep it and play continue?
Should the player be allowed the option of keeping that card - on the basis it was his but dealer error has caused them not to get it?
--- End quote ---
Short answer is no. It can create an unfair advantage. You can"t show cards at any point in the hand and this situation shouldn"t be treated any differently.
Im not saying youre wrong - i just think this is an interesting case - but how - if the whole table knows what the card is - can it create an "unfair" advantage - bearing in mind the player who is denied the card should also not be advantaged or disadvantaged as much as any other player - and he has done nothing wrong himself.
--- End quote ---
MarkTheShark:
--- Quote from: adilong1 on August 25, 2013, 16:22:51 PM ---
Wayne Parker
Chris Hiam
Barry Simpson
Stuart Oliver
Please
--- End quote ---
All still going - some better than others!
Wayne Parker - 10k
Chris Hiam - 34k
Barry Simpson - 11k
Stuart Oliver - 20k
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version